| Platinum | Cozumel Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | Milwaukee Grill |
| Silver | Bessie's Diner |
| Silver | Whiskey Ranch Bar and Grill |
| Bronze | Cozy Inn Chinese and American |
| Bronze | Italian House |
| Bronze | The Looking Glass |
| Top Pick | 5 Star Tainos |
| Top Pick | Backyard Barbeque |
| Top Pick | Citrus Cafe |
| Top Pick | Luke's Deli |