| Platinum | Tony & Maria's Italian Pizzeria |
| Gold | Jim's Pizza |
| Silver | Mac's Pizza Shack |
| Bronze | Milwaukee Street Pizza |
| Top Pick | Genisa Wine Bar |
| Top Pick | Lisa Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Sam's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Sneakers Sports Bar and Grill |
| Top Pick | The Ice Shantea |
| Top Pick | Willowdale Saloon |