| Platinum | Cone Zone |
| Gold | Dairy Queen |
| Gold | Frostie Freeze |
| Silver | Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Company |
| Bronze | The Ice Shantea |
| Top Pick | A&W All-American Food |
| Top Pick | Cold Stone Janesville |
| Top Pick | Culver's |
| Top Pick | Flippin' Frog Ice Cream & Tasty Treats |
| Top Pick | Luke's Deli |