| Platinum | Cozumel Mexican Restaurant |
| Gold | 5 Star Tainos |
| Silver | Hacienda Real |
| Bronze | San Miguel De Allende Mexican Restaurant Janesville |
| Top Pick | Anchor Inn |
| Top Pick | El Patron Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | La Casa Grande |
| Top Pick | LA Guacamaya Mexican |
| Top Pick | Taqueria Azteca |