| Platinum | 808 Cheesecake |
| Platinum | Mocha Moment |
| Gold | Hailey Sweet and Treats |
| Silver | Old Fashion Bakery |
| Bronze | Old Fashion Bakery of Beloit |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen |
| Top Pick | Lifes a Batch Cookies by Laura |
| Top Pick | Shaylee's Homemade Treats and More |
| Top Pick | Taryn's Tempting Treats |
| Top Pick | Treat Yourself Desserts |