| Platinum | Sunny + Olive |
| Gold | Threads Consignment |
| Silver | Agrace Thrift Store Janesville |
| Bronze | J & B Outlet/ Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | 608 Vintage |
| Top Pick | Best of Janesville Vintage Mall |
| Top Pick | Carousel Consignments |
| Top Pick | Gifts Thrift Store |
| Top Pick | Perfectly Plus Women's Consignment |
| Top Pick | The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center |